Ohio Schools to Vote on Separate Public and Private School Tournaments
COLUMBUS, Ohio — Ohio High School Athletic Association member schools will vote next May on a proposal to place public and non-public schools in separate postseason tournament divisions.
The OHSAA announced Wednesday that several public schools from Northeast Ohio’s Suburban League submitted a completed petition with enough signatures from member school principals to require a referendum.
Voting will take place May 1–15, 2027. Each member high school principal casts one vote on behalf of the school, and a simple majority is required for passage.
If approved, the change would take effect during the 2028–29 school year. The OHSAA Board of Directors would determine the number of public and non-public school divisions in each sport.
The proposal would also eliminate the competitive balance process, including adjustments applied to public schools with open enrollment.
OHSAA Executive Director Doug Ute said the association will hold meetings with member schools in early 2027 to explain the proposal and discuss its potential effects. He expressed concerns that separate tournaments could leave non-public divisions with relatively few schools and large differences in enrollment.
“The OHSAA is a reflection of our membership and we will create a forum to discuss and consider both perspectives,” Ute said.
Ohio schools have rejected similar proposals twice. A 1978 referendum failed with 83.9% voting against separation, while a 1993 proposal failed with 66.8% opposed.
Member schools approved the current competitive balance system in 2014, and it took effect during the 2017–18 school year. It uses varsity roster information to adjust tournament placement in soccer, girls volleyball, football, boys and girls basketball, softball and baseball.
According to the OHSAA, public schools won 56% of state championships in those sports from 2001–02 through 2016–17. Since competitive balance began, public schools have won 66% of those titles, compared with 34% for non-public schools.